Second Opinion

Supplements

Does it do what the label says?

Vitamins, creatine, beta-alanine and the rest, checked against the research.

Read this first. These pages explain what research found. They are not advice to take any supplements. Most supplement studies are in adults, and supplements are tested less extensively than medicines.

Want one checked? Suggest a supplement

Supplement reviews

Open a review to see what the studies found, what to do with that, and where the evidence runs thin.

Suggest a supplement

Submit a supplement for review

Tell us which supplement you want checked. We look at whether it works and how safe it is. We do not give doses.

Required. We email you to confirm we got it and again when it has been reviewed. It is never shown on the site.

How the two ratings work

Every supplement gets the same two ratings. They are about the supplement itself, so they can differ from the claim that sent you here.

Rating 1

Does it work?

  • No benefit shown. Good trials find nothing.
  • Unclear. Too little or conflicting evidence.
  • Small or limited. A real effect, but small or only in certain situations.
  • Clear benefit. Consistent benefit across good trials.

Rating 2

How safe is it?

  • Risks found. Studies or regulators report harm.
  • Not enough data. Not studied enough to say.
  • Minor side effects. Known mild effects, no serious harm found.
  • Low risk. Well studied, low risk at normal use.

A good safety rating never means skip the doctor. Supplements are tested less extensively than medicines, and products can differ from their labels. Effects can also be different from person to person, so a result in a study may not be what you get.

On the list

These are planned and not checked yet. Want one moved up? Send it in.

L-citrullineVitamin DMultivitaminsMore to come